Considering a tenant’s pet request? Five insurance checks landlords should make
Is your insurance ready for tenant pet requests?
Since 1 May 2026, landlords in England have had new responsibilities when considering tenants’ requests to keep pets under the Renters’ Rights Act 2025. With the NRLA reporting that pet-related questions are among its most common calls, it is increasingly important for landlords to understand the practical and insurance implications.
When considering a tenant’s request to keep a pet, landlords should assess how a pet could affect the property, from damage to fixtures and fittings to wear on outdoor areas. Reviewing property-management measures and insurance cover can help ensure these risks are managed appropriately.
Understanding pet-related risks
Many pet owners are responsible tenants, and the presence of a pet does not automatically lead to property damage. However, landlords may wish to consider the potential impact that a pet could have on both the building and landlord-owned contents during the tenancy.
Potential exposures can include:
- Scratched or damaged flooring, doors and skirting boards
- Chewed fixtures, fittings, furniture or soft furnishings
- Damage to carpets, curtains and other landlord-owned contents
- Staining, odours or damage requiring professional cleaning or replacement
- Damage to gardens, lawns, fencing or other external areas
- Accidental damage caused while pets are left unattended
The cost of repairing or replacing damaged items can quickly add up, particularly where multiple areas of a property are affected or specialist cleaning is required.
Depending on the policy, a landlord insurance policy may include buildings and contents insurance, property owners’ liability insurance, and property owners’ legal protection. With the change in legislation around tenant pets, some insurers have added pet damage cover to their policies, supporting landlords with this additional risk.
As a landlord, it’s important to remember that insurance policies can differ, so you should check whether your current arrangements include specific protection for damage caused by a tenant's pet.
Managing pet-related risks
Managing the risk starts with understanding the individual request. Before agreeing, you may want to ask for relevant details about the pet, such as its type, size and age, and discuss how it will be cared for at the property. Any conditions that are agreed should be clear, reasonable and recorded in writing as part of the tenancy documentation.
A detailed inventory can help establish the condition of the property before the pet moves in. Clear, dated photographs of flooring, doors, fixtures, furnishings and outdoor areas may provide useful evidence if damage is identified later. Additionally, you may wish to carry out proportionate inspections during the tenancy, in line with the required notice rules.
It is also sensible to check the terms of your landlord insurance when considering a pet request. Pet-related damage can affect both the building and a landlord’s contents, and cover can vary, so make sure you understand what protection is available, where it applies, the limits and excesses, and any steps needed for the cover to remain valid.
Protection designed for pet-related damage
A landlord insurance policy arranged by Gallagher may include dedicated protection for damage caused by tenants' domestic pets. Pet damage cover is available under both the buildings and landlord contents sections of the policy, subject to the policy terms, conditions and limits. This pet damage protection works alongside your wider buildings and contents cover and has been designed to ensure that the same damage is not claimed under more than one section of the policy.
The protection can provide:
- Up to £5,000 per incident
- Up to £10,000 in total during the policy year
- Cover to help with common forms of damage caused by tenants' domestic pets, including scratching, chewing and accidental damage
- A fixed excess, providing clarity at the point of claim
Pet damage cover may offer peace of mind when considering a new tenant with a pet or agreeing to an existing tenant’s request to keep one.
Important: Pet damage cover is insurer specific and is not included as standard across all landlord insurance policies arranged by Gallagher. Availability will depend on the insurer and policy selected following assessment of your individual requirements. Where provided, cover remains subject to the applicable policy terms, conditions, limits and excesses. If pet damage cover is important to you, please ensure this requirement is discussed with us when obtaining a quote so that available options can be considered.
Five insurance checks when considering a tenant's pet request
Whether you're reviewing a new tenancy application or considering a request from an existing tenant, the following checks may help you understand and manage the risks involved.
1. Check your current policy
Do not assume that damage caused by a tenant's pet is automatically covered. Review the policy wording and ask your provider to explain the protection available.
2. Confirm which property is protected
Check whether protection applies to the building, landlord’s contents or both, and note the limits and excesses.
3. Update the inventory
Record the condition of floors, doors, furniture, fixtures and outdoor areas before the pet moves in. Support the inventory with clear, dated photographs.
4. Keep your insurance provider informed
Tell your provider about relevant changes and check whether accepting a pet affects the policy.
5. Review your wider protection
Pet damage is only one consideration. Review whether your buildings, contents, liability, legal expenses and rent guarantee arrangements remain suitable for the tenancy.
Understand the cover you’re buying
If you're considering allowing pets in your rental property, it may be a good time to check whether your landlord insurance provides the protection you expect.
Whether you’re arranging or renewing cover, it is important that you’re clear about what protection is available, any policy conditions that may apply and whether the cover remains appropriate for your individual circumstances.
Gallagher has been providing insurance since 1927 and has experience in handling buildings and contents insurance policies for a wide range of landlords, working with specialist insurers.
Get a quote
Let your property with greater confidence by ensuring that you have suitable insurance in place to help protect your investment. Gallagher’s dedicated team can discuss your options and assist you in securing cover that offers peace of mind.
Prefer to speak to someone? Call Gallagher’s specialist team on 0800 612 0094.
The sole purpose of this article is to provide information on the issues covered. This article is not intended to give legal advice, and, accordingly, it should not be relied upon. It should not be regarded as a comprehensive statement of the law and/or market practice in this area. We make no claims as to the completeness or accuracy of the information contained herein or in the links which were live at the date of publication. You should not act upon (or should refrain from acting upon) information in this publication without first seeking specific legal and/or specialist advice. Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited and National Residential Landlords Association, an Introducer Appointed Representative of Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited, accept no liability for any inaccuracy, omission or mistake in this publication, nor will we be responsible for any loss which may be suffered as a result of any person relying on the information contained herein.
National Residential Landlords Association is an Introducer Appointed Representative of Arthur J. Gallagher Insurance Brokers Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered Office: Spectrum Building, 55 Blythswood Street, Glasgow, G2 7AT. Registered in Scotland. Company Number: SC108909.