PARTNERS AND SUPPLIERS

Your inventory is five years old, can it still support a deposit claim?

Sandy Bastin 18 November 2026

A detailed inventory is valuable evidence if a tenancy ends in a deposit dispute. But what happens when the tenancy has lasted five years and the property no longer looks quite like it did at check-in?

During a long tenancy, appliances are replaced, rooms are redecorated, repairs are completed and fixtures naturally age, so even an excellent original inventory may not tell the whole story several years later. However, that does not make an older inventory ineffective, landlords simply need to preserve it while also recording what happens between check-in and check-out.

The inventory is your starting point

A good check-in inventory should describe the property’s condition and cleanliness clearly, supported by dated photographs. Tenants should be able to check the report, suggest amendments and confirm whether it is accurate.

However, an inventory is only a snapshot of the move-in condition, it doesn’t capture everything that changes afterwards.

What might change during a five-year tenancy?

For example, the original inventory could record a five-year-old carpet in good condition. During the tenancy, a leak damages part of it and the landlord replaces it. Three years later, the tenant moves out and the new carpet is stained.

If the only evidence available is the original inventory, it will describe the older carpet and give the wrong age. Without a record of the replacement, it may be difficult to establish the condition of the new carpet when it was fitted or calculate a fair claim.

The same problem can arise when:

  • A landlord replaces an appliance or item of furniture;
  • Repairs alter the condition or decoration of a room;
  • The tenant receives permission to redecorate or install something;
  • A pet joins the household;
  • An item is removed from the property by agreement; or
  • Damage is identified and resolved during the tenancy.

Do not overwrite the original inventory

Do not edit the original check-in report; it should remain the permanent check-in record. Instead, create a dated trail of supporting evidence, such as interim reports, photographs, invoices or emails confirming agreed changes.

Where a landlord supplies a new item, record:

  • What was replaced and when;
  • Its make, model or quality where relevant; and
  • Its condition, supported by dated photographs.

Share significant updates with the tenant and allow them to raise any disagreement. Evidence created and shared at the time is more useful than a record produced years later after a dispute begins.

Interim inspections can fill the evidence gap

Reasonable periodic inspections help landlords identify repairs, discuss concerns and record how the property has changed.

A full new inventory is not needed on every visit. A concise report can record:

  • the overall condition of each area;
  • repairs or maintenance that are needed;
  • changes made since the previous inspection;
  • any damage requiring further investigation; and
  • the action agreed with the tenant.

Keep maintenance separate from possible tenant damage. A worn fitting or faulty appliance does not automatically establish tenant responsibility.

What would an adjudicator need to understand?

If a deposit claim is disputed, the landlord will normally need to demonstrate that they have suffered a loss because the tenant did not meet their responsibilities.

An adjudicator may need to understand:

  1. What was the condition at check-in?
  2. What changed during the tenancy, and when?
  3. Was the change agreed, repaired or replaced?
  4. What was the condition at check-out?
  5. What financial loss did the landlord suffer?

The original inventory remains central, but interim reports, repair records, messages and invoices provide the missing context.

A longer tenancy means more wear and tear

Even with strong evidence, landlords must allow for fair wear and tear by considering the tenancy length, occupants, original condition, quality and expected lifespan of an item.

An older item cannot be expected to remain in its original condition or justify charging the tenant for a brand-new replacement. Any claim should reflect its remaining value and damage beyond reasonable use.

Make the record manageable

Digital property inspection platforms can help landlords keep check-ins, interim inspections and check-outs connected in one place.

TDS works in partnership with Inventory Hive, whose cloud-based platform enables landlords to create paperless reports, retain dated evidence and compare the property’s condition at different stages of the tenancy. The aim is not to create more administration, but to make sure important changes do not disappear into an email inbox or become dependent on someone’s memory.

Keep the full story, not just the first and last page

A five-year-old inventory is still valuable. Its strength will depend on whether it is accurate and supported by records showing what happened next. By retaining the original check-in report, documenting significant changes and carrying out proportionate interim inspections, landlords can build a fairer and more reliable record. That can make discussions at check-out easier, support reasonable deposit claims and help both parties resolve disagreements before formal dispute resolution is needed.

Landlords and property professionals who want to strengthen their inventory and inspection processes can also explore TDS Academy’s specialist training.

Further support from TDS

For guidance, templates and tools to help you manage deposits with confidence, visit the TDS Help Centre. 

Relevant Topics

Sandy Bastin
About the author
Director of Resolution, TDS

Sandy Bastin is a qualified solicitor with many years’ experience practising and specialising in real estate, Sandy joined Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS) in 2008 and is now Director of Resolution at TDS Adjudication Services. Sandy is responsible for recruiting and training TDS adjudicators, providing continued support and mentoring to include quality assurance activity to ensure the high standards expected from TDS adjudication decisions are met.